One of the largest music platforms of the world has been a scene of a fiery incident, and it has caused worldwide outrage and criticism by the highest political figures and had severe repercussions on the careers of an upcoming British music duo.
The U.S government, has officially cancelled the entry visas of punk-rap group, Bob Vylan, after they encouraged the crowd to chant, “Death, death to the IDF”- a direct insult to the Israeli military during their Saturday performance at the Glastonbury Festival in the U.K.
The chant by the group that was recorded during a BBC livestream soon sparked a wave of controversy not only in Britain but also in other countries. Although BBC apologized saying they should have switched off the live feed sooner, the outrage did not end here.
BBC, Festival Under Fire
According to a statement made by the BBC, who aired the performance, it does not condone incitement to violence even though the network believes in freedom of expression.
The BBC said it was horrified by the antisemitic remarks made by Bob Vylan and that such sentiments cannot appear on our airwaves. But hindsight is 20/20, we should have drawn the stream. We are sorry this was not the case.”
The prime minister of Britain, Keir Starmer, and other cabinet members also criticized the performance, increasing pressure on the BBC after they gave a delayed reaction.
The promoters of the Glastonbury, one of the most renowned music festivals in the world, stated the band was taking this act too far.
The management of the festival wrote: at Glastonbury, there is no space fore antisemitism, hate speech, or violence provocations.
U.S. Responds Quickly
The most severe reaction was by the United States.
Revoking the entry visas of Bob Vylan which would have resulted in the cancellation of their upcoming tour of America, Deputy Secretary of State Christopher Landau confirmed that through a post on social media. The group was due to play more than a dozen cities throughout the U.S., beginning in late October.
Landau wrote on Monday that foreigners who promote violence and hatred are unwanted visitors to the state.
This move by the U.S. is a big diplomatic reaction to the performance of the band in Glastonbury and a reaction that has been compounded by the increasing alarm over hate speech in the face of the increased tension in the world regarding the Israel-Gaza conflict.
Bob Vylan Answers: I Said, What I Said
When faced with the backlash, Bob Vylan, a band with a reputation for using deliberately politically charged lyrics and remaining anonymous onstage because of the potential consequences, also failed to retract their comments.
Instead, they stood their ground through a long Instagram post captioned as :I said what I said.
The two clarified that they used such expressions to make younger generations speak out in the quest to achieve justice and social change.
They wrote, “Let us show them, loudly and visibly, what is the right thing to do when we want and need change.” and make them feel us marching in the streets, the canvassing on ground level, the organizing via internet, and making noise about us on any and all stages that we can be given.
Although their message found some fans, there was considerable concern among many other fans, festival-goers, and community leaders that the chant had crossed the line between protest and dangerous rhetoric.
Police Investigation in Progress
Police in southwest England have since initiated an inquiry into whether the chant had breached any criminal provisions, such as hate speech or calls to violence.
The band has not been charged yet, though police have stated that they were examining all recordings of the performance and interviewing the festival organization team and security personnel.
Glastonbury and Bob Vylan
Glastonbury festival held on a Somerset farm attracts more than 200,000 people all around the world. It has been on air for over 50 years and has gained notoriety over its eclectic selection of music and vocal activism.
Bob Vylan is an independent punk-rap band that has established itself as an artist that covers controversial subjects in lyrical content, such as racism and police brutality. They are famous to wear masks or mask their identities when they perform and also appear in the media.
Their music is always mixed in such a polarised manner that they give out genres and messages that are controversial and controversial to the point that their chant at Glastonbury appears to have driven the wedge further.
But not the Only Controversy at Glastonbury
Ahead of that performance was Bob Vylan, a British-based politically defiant band that has aroused controversy in the past due to comments seen as pro-Hamas or anti-Conservative.
It was reported that BBC decided not to stream the set of Kneecap as they feared controversial remarks in their gigs.
Kneecap also issued a statement in which they denied any association with extremist groups, stating that they never did and never will support Hamas or Hezbollah. They also had to apologise to the relatives of two British lawmakers who had already been murdered after they were accused of referring to Conservative lawmakers.
Hate Speech vs. Free Speech: the Debate Grows to Divide Public
This has caused a greater debate on freedom of speech, censorship, and hate speech in public performances in both the U.K. and the U.S. Other band supporters claim that the band has right to express political views on stage, most specifically at a festival that has a long-standing protest culture.
Critics, however, including Jewish advocacy groups and foreign observers, have pointed out that there is a distinction between political dissent and advocating death to the members of a certain ethnic or national group.
To date, Bob Vylan is on the list as being prohibited from entering the U.S., and their American supporters are disillusioned and polarized.
It is yet to be shown whether this event will restrict artistic expression further or require greater control over large-scale live events.
However, there is one thing that is very clear: the ripple effect of one chant on a Saturday afternoon at Glastonbury was felt way beyond the rolling hills of Somerset.
About The Author
